Monday, January 26, 2015

Evolutionary (Science-Directed) Socialism: Part-V ---BY SRI BHAGWAT PRASAD RATH

        Science helps in  building a sane, peaceful, nonviolent society in a very big area (an area equal to the sum of the areas of the two ancient civilizations: Egyptian and Mesopotamian). 

The Mahabharata says that no sacrifice (Yagna) was existing in Satyayuga (The age of the Sindhu civilization).  The elite of society accepted Yoga as the most important philosophy and practice of life.  Yoga, Samkhya and Lokayat were considered so important in society that Kautilya in his book Arthasastra called them the light of all systems of knowledge (Sastras) and the only ideal way to deal with all activities. He asserted that Aanwikshiki (Yoga, Samkhya and Lokayat) was the store house of the core material of all Dharmas (religions).  Aanwikshiki was a perfectly rational system of knowledge.  Kautilya does not give a high place to the Vedas which he calls TRAYI. Aanwikshiki was the guiding system of the Sindhu civilization.   Aanwikshikians occupied the highest seat of honour in the Sindhu civilization.    Aanwikshikians came from all tribes. Any one could become a Yogi.   Charvak talked with the Pandavas as a representative of a respectable group of Brahmins who did not accept gifts (Santiparva).  Lokayatikas practice Yoga and also may come from low caste people (Lokayata by D. P. Chattopadhya, Indian council of philosophical research, New Delhi).      

Non-violence was accepted as the main value by all Aanwikshikians.  Only women could have discovered such philosophies.  No hunter society would have accepted non violence as the supreme value of life. 

R. Rajgopalan   writes in his book, ‘Indus Valley’, ‘How was this vast and complex civilization managed? The earlier view was that there was a strong central authority like a ruler.  Only then could they have had the common features we see. Public buildings like the granaries and the Great Bath also supported this view.  It was also felt that different social classes must have existed for maintaining the whole system.  Skeletal biology contradicts this view.  If social classes had existed, then some people would have had better food and hence better growth.  This would be shown in their teeth and bones.  Now 350 skeletons from five major sites do not show any significant difference! There are also no royal tombs.  It is possible that the Indus Civilization was maintained at an advanced level without social classes, central authority and warfare! If we can prove this, the Indus Civilization would be shown to have been a truly exceptional one – unmatched even by today’s democracies and republics!’

The Mahabharata proves concretely that such a classless, casteless and war –free society existed in the Indus valley.  This society was evidently a socialist society. 

Yoga was the greatest discovery of the Indian scientists of the pre-Vedic period.  Pre-Vedic Yoga does not accept miracles and mysticism.  Yoga should be subjected to all the tests of modern science and only those parts which pass the tests can be accepted. Human mind can be changed through Yoga.  We can not build a socialist society with the present decadent mind possessed by the elite (particularly the rulers) through out the world. Eminent scientists interacted with the Dalai Lama and were surprised to find fully controlled noble minds among the Tibetan Yogis. Lamaism in Tibet got contaminated by the non scientific Tantra and the theory of rebirth.  Still its Yoga system retains its original vigour.  How this system was tested in the laboratory makes interesting reading.  We can hope for a better future for humanity if our elite accept this God-free Yoga system which abhors miracles and mysticism. The Buddha’s mind was a gift of the Yoga system.   

Below are given the results of some tests of the Yoga system by the scientists in the laboratory.

The Neuroanatomy of compassion

While the fMRI findings were quite preliminary, the EEG analysis had already borne rich fruit in the comparison between Oser (a Lama Yogi) at rest and while meditating on compassion. Most striking was a dramatic increase in key electrical activity known as gamma in the left middle frontal gyrus, a zone of the brain Davidson’s previous research had pinpointed as a locus for positive emotions.  In research with close to two hundred people, Davidson’s lab had found that when people have high levels of such brain activity in that specific site of the left prefrontal cortex, they simultaneously report feelings such as happiness, enthusiasm, joy, high energy, and alertness……… …………………………………

In short, Oser’s brain shift during compassion (Yoga) seemed to reflect an extremely pleasant mood.  The very act of concerns for others well-being, it seems, creates a greater state of well-being within oneself.  The finding lends scientific support to an observation often made by the Dalai Lama: that the person doing a meditation on compassion for all beings is the immediate beneficiary.  (Among other benefits of cultivating compassion, as described in  classic Buddhist texts, are being loved by people and animals, having a serene mind, sleeping and walking peacefully, and having pleasant dreams)…………

Like all reflexes, the startle reflects activity of the brain stem and is the most primitive, reptilian part of the brain.  Like other brain stem responses- and unlike those of the autonomic nervous system, such as a rate at which the heart beats-the startle reflex lies beyond the range of voluntary regulation.  So far as brain science understands, the mechanisms that control the startle reflex cannot be modified by any intentional act. ……………….

(Paul Ekman is professor of psychology and director of the Human Interaction Laboratory at the University Of California Medical School in San in San Francisco).

Paul Ekman explained to the Dalai Lama.  “When Oser tries to suppress the startle, it almost disappeared.  We’ve never found anyone who can do that.  Nor have any other researchers.  This is a spectacular accomplishment.  We don’t have any idea of the anatomy that would allow him to suppress the startle reflex.”

(DESTRUCTIVE EMOTIONS AND HOW WE CAN OVERCOME THEM by Daniel Goleman.  Daniel Goleman is co-chair of the Consortium for Research on Emotional Intelligence in the Graduate School of Applied and Professional Psychology at Rutgers University).
To repeat, the Buddha’s mind was not a gift of nature.  By practicing Yoga he built the best known mind of the ancient world. Bertrand Russell had a life long struggle to discover whether human values were subjective or objective.  Yogis were the only people in the world who discovered that human values were fixed by nature on the pleasure principle (SUKHA) not of the limbic   brain (the animal brain), but of the pre-frontal cortex. Freud‘s psychology was about the limbic brain only. Except the Yogis, no scientist or psychologist has applied nature’s pleasure principle to the pre-frontal cortex.      

To quote DHAMMAPADA by the Buddha:-

i.                    Mind precedes all mental states.  Mind is their chief; they are all mind-wrought.  If with an impure mind a person speaks or acts, suffering follows him like the wheel that follows the foot of the ox.
ii.                  Mind precedes all mental states.  Mind is their chief; they are all mind-wrought.  If with a pure mind a person speaks or acts, happiness follows him like his never-departing shadow.

In the book ENLIGHTENMENT: East and West Paulos Mar Gregorios,  president of the world council of churches wrote, ‘Draw portraits of a tight-lipped Voltaire, of a morose and intensely  self-preoccupied Kant or Schopenhauer, of a Locke or a Hume, a Kier-kegaard or a Wittgenstein, a Nietzsche, a Diderot, a Sartre.  Keep these portraits on one side.  Draw portraits of Buddha, Asvaghosa, Nagarjuna, Dharmakirti, Chandrakirti, Dignaga, Vachaspati Misra, Sridhara and keep them on the other side……….’

‘Ben-Ami Scharfstein, an Israeli philosopher at Tel-Aviv University, has done us a singular favour by trying to relate the thought of many of the Western philosophers to their personal lives.  The picture that emerges is indeed fascinating.  I cite a sample passage from the book:
‘Therefore, when I think of the atomism of Hume, James, Russell and Wittgenstein, I conclude that it must have been their inward experience that made them receptive to the atomic disintegration of the self.  To Russell, body and mind were only logical constructions, and the whole person only ‘relations of the thoughts to each other and to the body.’

…Hume, James, Russell and Wittgenstein underwent deep depressions, and all were tempted by suicide…..

As we follow Professor Scharfstein on a guided tour of the personal lives of the major Western philosophers, relating their life-experiences to their philosophical positions, one is impressed by the fact that very few of them had attained anything like the personal integration that we associate with our great Indian philosophers’.  

Can we prevent climate change without observing the Yogic value of APARIGRAHA (minimize your wants to the greatest extent possible) or establish a socialist society without accepting the Yogic value of ASTEYA (the principle of looking after others’ welfare before thinking of one’s own welfare)?  Can we save the animal world (read the chapter DEEP ECOLOGY from the book the web of life written by FRITJOF CAPRA) without accepting the Yogic value of ‘non-violence’? Can we save the world from wars of nations and angry communities if the Yogic values of Maitri and Karuna (Compassion) are not taken into consideration?  To quote the Buddha :

Dhammapada (4) “He abused me, he struck me, be overpowered me, he robbed me.”  Those who do not harbor such thoughts still their hatred.

Dhammapada (5). “Hatred is never appeased by hatred in this world.  By non-hatred alone is hatred appeased.  This is a Law eternal.’

Gandhi made these principles practical for large communities fighting for justice.  Ambedkar was guided by Buddha’s   teachings and fought against the age old injustice done to a big disadvantaged community (Dalits in India).   The Buddha was the only religious preacher in the world who stressed ‘rationality’ and the scientific principle of fallibility rather than ‘belief’ in the field of religion.  His mission was to place religion on the same pedestal as science.  Unfortunately the Buddhists the world over made the Buddha a God and violated his teachings.  The belief – stressing religions like Hinduism, Christianity, Islam and the Sikh religions have become war fields.  So world thinkers like Einstein   and Russell have lost their faith in all religions.

The Buddha and Mohabira’s age in India was the twilight period of the philosophy of the Sindhu civilization. Both the Buddha and Mohabira were inheritors of the patriarchal legacy of the past Vedic age.  Fortunately they retained many matricentric values of the past.    Among these values nonviolence, Aparigraha, Maitri and Koruna (compassion) were the principal ones. In the fifth and sixth centuries these values lost their importance.  Might became right and even females were worshipped in the form of warriors. To day, all religions have lost their humanist outlook.  The feudal value of loyalty (Bhakti) replacing the principle of Maitri for all living beings, the priests’ embracing of extravagant rituals based on the trader’s values of conspicuous consumption in the name of the deity, the superstitious fanatic attachment to obscure litanies, Mantras, miracles and mysticism, the Indulgence in demonized violence and ruthless imperial exploitation, the making of women into male slaves:  all combine to create a religious hell for humanity.  Religion is not the only opium for humanity.  Every predatory institution mentioned by Thorstein Veblen and also by C.  Wright Mills,   a product of the male brain, bolstered by patriarchal values, is like opium. Feudal and capitalism-fostered values rule societies through decadent cultures.  Human brain develops neural mechanisms consonant with these devastating cultures.  Insanity of large groups of people is the result.  The US spends 54% of its annual budget for maintaining its war machines.  All ideologies of angry people favouring violent revolutions fail because human brain accustomed to constant violence develops neural mechanisms that make the revolutionaries unfit for democratic socialism.   

Arrian a Greek scholar, wrote, ‘Megasthenes described seven categories of Indian castes. The first one is that of “the Sophists’… who are not so numerous as the others, but hold the supreme place of dignity and honour- for they are under no necessity of doing any bodily labour at all, or of contributing from the produce of their labour anything to the common stock, nor indeed is any duty binding on them except to perform the sacrifices offered to the gods on behalf of the state.. To this class the knowledge of divination among the Indians is exclusively restricted and none but a sophist is allowed to practice that art…. These sages go naked, living during the winter in the open air to enjoy the sunshine… They live upon the fruits which each season produces and on the barks of trees…..’ (Scholars tell us that fear of death by Indra forced them to accept sacrifice as a ritual, otherwise Yoga was the only value they cherished).

CASTE: The Emergence of the South Asian Social System by Morton Klass.


(To be continued in Evolutionary (Science-Directed) Socialism: Part-VI)

Bhagwat Prasad Rath,
3rd Line, Roith Colony,
At/PO/Dist. – Rayagada –2
PIN- 765002, Odisha.
Phone No. 06856-235092



No comments:

Post a Comment